The Imperfective Puzzle in Korean
نویسنده
چکیده
Much attention in recent Korean linguistics literature has been paid to the imperfective puzzle surrounding the periphrastic marker -ko iss-. This marker corresponds to English BE + -ing in a way but, unlike its English counterpart, -ko (KO) is a connective meaning „and‟, and iss(ISS) literally means „exist‟, though it is often glossed as BE or Copular in the literature. The imperfective puzzle usually refers to the phenomenon in which sentences containing KO ISS sentences are two-ways ambiguous when occurring with so-called „put on‟ type verbs (e.g., Kim 1986, Kim 1990, Lee 1991, Kim 1993, Ahn 1995, Son 2004, Lee 2008). For instance, (1) can be interpreted as describing the action of Yoona putting clothes on herself or the state of the clothes being on her. (Here and throughout, the action reading will be labeled a „progressive (P) state‟ reading and the state reading a „result (R) state‟ reading. Also, to stay neutral in citing examples from the existing literature, the morphemes participating in the formation of a periphrastic imperfective marker will not be glossed.)
منابع مشابه
A Fresh Look at the Ambiguity Puzzle of KO ISS Imperfective in Korean
The ambiguity of KO ISS has been much discussed in the literature (see, e.g., works cited above). But it is yet to receive a satisfactory treatment on both empirical and theoretical grounds. It poses a challenge to Lee (2008), for instance: Lee claims that the imperfective marker always selects for a VP that takes an actor subject. As illustrated by (3), however, it is compatible with a sentenc...
متن کاملTemporal Reference Frames and the Imperfective Paradox
This paper brings new evidence to bear on the topic of the Imperfective Paradox – a semantic puzzle involving tense-aspectual categories that lack completion entailments. The lack of completion entailments is usually associated with the so-called progressive and conative readings, illustrated in the Russian sentences in (1) and (2) respectively. In these examples, the matrix event described by ...
متن کاملA birelational analysis of the Russian imperfective
This paper provides two puzzles for a theory of aspect. The first concerns the quirky behavior of the Russian imperfective with regard to its culmination properties: it seems to function like the perfect aspect in certain cases, but like the progressive in others. The other puzzle concerns how the Russian imperfective constrains the temporal location of a described event: it relates distinct ev...
متن کاملThe Acquisition of Imperfective Aspect Marking in Korean as a Second Language by Japanese Learners
This paper investigates the developmental process through which L2 learners acquire two „imperfective‟ aspect markers in Korean, -ko iss(progressive and resultative) and -a iss(resultative) which attempts to identify language-general and language-specific patterns in the L2 acquisition of the Korean imperfective aspect by Japanese learners by comparing the results with previous research. Study ...
متن کاملThe Effect of Instructional Order on the L2 Acquisition of the Korean Imperfective Aspect
It has been widely observed that in the L2 acquisition of aspect, progressive/imperfective marking is acquired earlier with activity verbs than with achievement verbs (the Aspect Hypothesis; Andersen & Shirai, 1994). This pattern has been seen repeatedly in Japanese -te i(e.g., Shirai & Kurono, 1998), and in -ko issand -a issin L2 Korean (e.g., Lee & Kim, 2007). However, Ishida (2004) found her...
متن کامل